Summary
Under the current UK Emissions Trading Scheme (UK ETS), UK refineries already incur almost £400m costs per year on their carbon emissions which many refineries in the US, the Middle East, India and elsewhere do not have to pay. The result is that these overseas refineries out-compete UK refineries – costing jobs, increasing emissions and weakening fuel security. At the same time, imported fuels from elsewhere will create at least as much emissions as the refineries that have closed.
It is widely expected that November's UK-EU summit will lead to linkage on emissions trading. Speculation since early 2025 regarding the Government's intention to link the ETS Schemes, has prompted a significant increase in the market price of UK Allowances (UKA), with the gap with EU Allowances (EUA) reducing by over £20 per tonne. This increase represents more than £1 billion of additional costs to industries within scope of the UK ETS. For the refining sector alone, the increase is almost £100m. These price changes have already been seen in response to the announcement, with greater impacts on costs possible. Such impacts will depend on the design of future linkage and the extent to which the UK is willing to agree to EU-optimised ETS rules when there are notable differences between our respective markets and manufacturing industries.
As a result of higher ETS costs and the ongoing risk of competition from imports not subject to equivalent carbon pricing, remaining UK refineries and other heavy industries are at an increasing risk. Further refinery closures would undermine the UK’s fuels resilience as liquid fuels account for over 95% of transport energy demand. The knock-on effects on industrial communities would be profound and include lost infrastructure and a loss of the expertise needed to enable industrial decarbonisation and growth.
Links
- Press release: Fuels Industry UK’s concerns around UK-EU carbon market linkage
- UK ETS and free allowances
Our concerns
1. Total market allowance pool: UK should retain control over total UK share of allowances available. We remain concerned that any pre-commitment to match EU ambitions inherently precludes the possibility of the UK retaining control.
2. Industry Cap Reduction Rate (all allowances): the same should apply to the UK specific industry cap within the context of UK cost containment scheme. In other words, the UK retains its own industry cap. Our concern is that it is not mathematically possible to retain control of free allowance policy and to have a calculated CBAM equal to zero. What the sector needs is assurance that there will be a mutual CBAM exemption even if the two respective calculated CBAMs are non-zero.
3. CBAM for fuels: with respect to the degree of alignment necessary for respective UK and EU CBAM’s to be judged as equivalent and therefore such that no border adjustment between the UK and EU applies if and when a CBAM is introduced for the sector: a requirement for mathematical equivalence is not acceptable, however a waiver could be. One of our main policy asks of this year’s Budget is to introduce a CBAM for refined products from January 2029, and we would ask that this is factored into any future negotiations.
4. Conditionality: no loss of ETS allowances if conditionality criteria are not met. No loss of allowances if conditionality criteria are not met must be a red line for the UK government in negotiations. It is in the interests of both UK and EU businesses to pursue such a policy, with conditionality only viable as a policy if there are decarbonisation schemes open to manufactured foods including fuel and refined products. Such pathways are often the result of government schemes and come with a high deal of uncertainty and lack of pace.
5. Decarbonisation trajectory and ambition: retain the right for UK to apply judgment and pragmatism on the UK trajectory. A commitment to matching UK and EU ambitions represents a pre-existing constraint on the retention of control. There is a need for the UK to take a divergent pathway as required to match its own trading relationships and evolving decarbonisation pathway.
6. Market stability reserve and cost containment mechanism: implement the proposals made on approach and retain the ability to be pragmatic on price. The sector needs assurance that there will be a mutual CBAM exemption even if the two respective calculated CBAMs are non-zero.
7. Indirect Cost Compensation scheme post review: refining becomes eligible for indirect energy cost compensation. Industry needs assurance that the much-delayed process to change eligibility criteria and include refineries, as is the case in many EU countries, will move forward at pace.